1 School of Mechanical Engineering and Mechanics, Xiangtan University, Xiangtan 411105, Hunan, China 2 School of Measuring and Optical Engineering, Nanchang Hangkong University, Nanchang 330063, China
Abstract: Honeycomb sandwich structure is a laminated composite material with excellent mechanical properties, which has been widely used in aerospace, construction and automobile industries. Due to the complexity of its structure and service conditions, honeycomb sandwich structures are prone to various defects such as skin-core interface debonding, skin delamination, inclusions, core lattice deformation, collapse, nodefracture, water accumulation, etc., during the manufacturing and service stages. Therefore, it is of great significance to carry out research on nondestructive testing (NDT) methods for honeycomb sandwich structures. In this paper, the NDT methods for honeycomb sandwich structures reported in domestic and international literature are reviewed, and the principles, application advantages and limitations of these methods are analyzed. Afterwards, the hybrid testing methods that combine multiple single methods for detecting all defects in the honeycomb sandwich structures are briefly outlined, and it is pointed out that the application of intelligent algorithms enables the quantification and classification of potential defects in honeycomb sandwich structures. Finally, a brief conclusion regarding the research status and application trend of the NDT methods for honeycomb sandwich structures is given.
通讯作者:
* 徐志远,湘潭大学机械工程与力学学院副教授、硕士研究生导师。2007年华中科技大学机械设计制造及其自动化专业本科毕业,2012年华中科技大学测试计量技术及仪器专业博士毕业后到湘潭大学工作至今。目前主要从事电磁无损检测与评估、工程测试与信号处理等方面的研究工作。发表论文40余篇,包括NDT&E International、Journal of Nondestructive Evaluation、Sensors and Actuators A:Physical、Nondestructive Testing and Evaluation等。xuzhiyuan@xtu.edu.cn
1 Ramnath B V, Alagarraja K, Elanchezhian C. Materials Today:Procee-dings, 2019, 16, 859. 2 Jiang H, Ji Y, Hu Y, et al. Composite Structures, 2022, 289, 115486. 3 Yang H. Pulsed eddy current testing technology of aluminum honeycomb structure material corrosion defects. Master’s Thesis, Nanchang Hangkong University, China, 2017 (in Chinese). 杨浩. 铝蜂窝结构材料腐蚀缺陷的脉冲涡流检测技术研究. 硕士学位论文, 南昌航空大学, 2017. 4 Onyibo E C, Safaei B. Reports in Mechanical Engineering, 2022, 3(1), 283. 5 Wei X, Li D, Xiong J. Composites Science and Technology, 2019, 184, 107878. 6 Nguyen M Q, Jacombs S S, Thomson R S, et al. Composite Structures, 2005, 67(2), 217. 7 Zhao P C. Mechanical properties of honeycomb sandwich composites material with debonds. Master’s Thesis, Harbin Engineering University, China, 2009 (in Chinese). 赵鹏成. 含缺陷复合材料蜂窝夹层结构力学性能研究. 硕士学位论文, 哈尔滨工程大学, 2009. 8 Thwaites S, Clark N H. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1995, 187(2), 253. 9 Meo M, Vignjevic R, Marengo G. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, 2005, 47(9), 1301. 10 Mahmoudabadi M Z, Sadighi M. Aerospace Science and Technology, 2019, 88, 273. 11 Ibrahim M E. Composites Part A:Applied Science and Manufacturing, 2014, 64, 36. 12 Wang B, Zhong S, Lee T L, et al. Advances in Mechanical Engineering, 2020, 12(4), 1687814020913761. 13 Nsengiyumva W, Zhong S, Lin J, et al. Composite Structures, 2021, 256, 112951. 14 Hassani S, Mousavi M, Gandomi A H. Sensors, 2022, 22(1), 153. 15 Güemes A, Fernandez-Lopez A, Pozo A R, et al. Journal of Composites Science, 2020, 4(1), 13. 16 Jodhani J, Handa A, Gautam A, et al. Materials Today:Proceedings, 2022, 12, 2214. 17 Wang B, He P, Kang Y, et al. Journal of Sensors, 2022, 2022, 5462237. 18 Schnars U, Henrich R. In:Proceedings of the Conference on Damage in Composite Materials. Stuttgart, Germany, 2006, pp. 18. 19 Wronkowicz-Katunin A. Fatigue of Aircraft Structures, 2018 (10), 73. 20 Hsu D K. Journal of Sandwich Structures & Materials, 2009, 11(4), 275. 21 Gholizadeh S. Procedia Structural Integrity, 2016, 1, 50. 22 Mukhtar A, Khattak M A, et al. Journal of Advanced Research in Applied Mechanics, 2016, 20(1), 12. 23 Towsyfyan H, Biguri A, Boardman R, et al. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics, 2020, 33(3), 771. 24 Qu Y L, Ning N, Zhan S Z. Aeronautical Manufacturing Technology, 2011, 392(20), 78 (in Chinese). 曲亚林, 宁宁, 詹绍正. 航空制造技术, 2011, 392(20), 78. 25 Liu S P, Liu F F, Li L G, et al. Aeronautical Manufacturing Technology, 2019, 62(14), 14 (in Chinese). 刘松平, 刘菲菲, 李乐刚, 等. 航空制造技术, 2019, 62(14), 14 (in Chinese). 26 Hu T P, Gao L M, Yang H N. Aeronautical Manufacturing Technology, 2018, 61(19), 50 (in Chinese). 胡婷萍, 高丽敏, 杨海楠. 航空制造技术, 2018, 61(19), 50. 27 Zhou Z G, Sun G K, Ma B Q. Science & Technology Review. 2014, 32(9), 15 (in Chinese). 周正干, 孙广开, 马保全. 科技导报, 2014, 32(9), 15. 28 Li G C, Li Y Q, He Y L. In:Advanced Materials Research, Trans Tech Publications Ltd, Switzerland, 2014, pp. 3349. 29 Jandejsek I, Jakubek J, Jakubek M, et al. Journal of Instrumentation, 2014, 9(5), C05062. 30 Meng W, Zhang H. Nondestructive Testing, 2014, 36(2), 17(in Chinese). 孟伟, 张海. 无损检测, 2014, 36(2), 17. 31 Jiang H J, Sheng T, Chen L, et al. Nondestructive Testing, 2020, 42(6), 54 (in Chinese). 江海军, 盛涛, 陈力, 等. 无损检测, 2020, 42(6), 54. 32 Negi P S, Koodalil D, Balasubramaniam K. In:Advances in Non Destructive Evaluation:Proceedings of NDE 2020, Singapore:Springer Nature Singapore, Singapore, 2022, pp. 401. 33 Cheng J. Nondestructive testing of carbon fibre reinforced polymer compo-sites using eddy current method eddy current method. Master’s Thesis, Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, China, 2015 (in Chinese). 程军. 碳纤维复合材料的电磁涡流无损检测技术研究. 硕士学位论文, 南京航空航天大学, 2015. 34 Liu B, Sheng T, Zheng J H. Laser & Infrared, 2020, 50(4), 413 (in Chinese). 刘斌, 盛涛, 郑金华. 激光与红外, 2020, 50(4), 413. 35 Zhang D D, Ren J J, Li L J, et al. Acta Photonica Sinica, 2019, 48(2), 163 (in Chinese). 张丹丹, 任姣姣, 李丽娟, 等. 光子学报, 2019, 48(2), 163. 36 Yang S H, Kim K B, Oh H G, et al. NDT & E International, 2013, 57, 45. 37 Seguel F, Meruane V. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2018, 417, 1. 38 Zhang W. Research on nondestructive testing techniques for honeycomb composites. Master’s Thesis, Tiangong University, China, 2019 (in Chinese). 张微. 蜂窝复合材料无损检测技术的研究. 硕士学位论文, 天津工业大学, 2019. 39 Wang Z, Li S N, Guo G P. Nondestructive Testing, 2012, 34(6), 29 (in Chinese). 王铮, 李硕宁, 郭广平. 无损检测, 2012, 34(6), 29. 40 Ai C A, Zeng Y P, Li J, et al. Nondestructive Testing, 2012, 34(9), 50 (in Chinese). 艾春安, 曾一平, 李剑, 等. 无损检测, 2012, 34(9), 50. 41 Wu G H, Lin J M, Ren J L, et al. Nondestructive Testing, 2011, 33(2), 35 (in Chinese). 邬冠华, 林俊明, 任吉林, 等. 无损检测, 2011, 33(2), 35. 42 Sikdar S, Mirgal P, Banerjee S, et al. Composites Part B:Engineering, 2019, 158, 179. 43 Zhang S X, Wang Y, Li M C. Nondestructive Testing Technology, 2002, 18(6), 38 (in Chinese). 张淑香, 王珏, 李明昌. 无损探伤, 2002, 18(6), 38. 44 You Q W. Response analysis on small-mass impact of honeycomb sandwich composites. Master’s Thesis, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, China, 2019 (in Chinese). 尤青文. 蜂窝夹层复合材料小质量冲击响应分析. 硕士学位论文, 上海交通大学, 2019. 45 Mei M X. Application research on damage detection based on acoustic emission technique. Master’s Thesis, Southeast University, China, 2016 (in Chinese). 梅明星. 基于声发射技术的损伤检测应用研究. 硕士学位论文, 东南大学, 2016. 46 Wu G H, Liu S Y, Wu W, et al. Nondestructive Testing, 2013, 35(12), 42 (in Chinese). 邬冠华, 刘斯以, 吴伟, 等. 无损检测, 2013, 35(12), 42. 47 Yu Y H, Choi J H, Kweon J H, et al. Composite Structures, 2006, 75(1-4), 163. 48 Rishikesan V, Chaturvedi B, Arunachalam N. Procedia Manufacturing, 2021, 53, 664. 49 Wu W, Liu S Y, Wu G H. Materials Reports, 2013, 27(12), 110 (in Chinese). 吴伟, 刘斯以, 邬冠华. 材料导报, 2013, 27(12), 110. 50 Grondel S, Assaad J, Delebarre C, et al. Ultrasonics, 2004, 42(1-9), 819. 51 Wronkowicz A, Dragan K, Lis K. Composite Structures, 2018, 203, 71. 52 Scruby C B, Drain L E. Laser ultrasonics:techniques and applications. Routledge, USA, 2019 pp. 462. 53 Bojun L, Jian L. In:2022 IEEE International Conference on Electrical Engineering, Big Data and Algorithms (EEBDA). China, 2022, pp. 1093. 54 Wei Q, Jin C E, Zhou J P, et al. Nondestructive Testing, 2016, 38(8), 6 (in Chinese). 危荃, 金翠娥, 周建平, 等. 无损检测, 2016, 38(8), 6. 55 Li H, Zhou Z. Applied Sciences, 2019, 9(2), 283. 56 Chimenti D E. Ultrasonics, 2014, 54(7), 1804. 57 Zhu Q. Non-destructive testing research based on laser ultrasonic technique for laminated structure. Master’s Thesis, Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, China, 2016 (in Chinese). 朱倩. 基于激光超声技术的层合结构无损检测方法研究. 硕士学位论文, 南京航空航天大学, 2016. 58 Zhou Z, Sun G, Li Y. Aeronautical Manufacturing Technology, 2016, 4, 30. 59 Girolamo D, Girolamo L, Yuan F G. In:AIP Conference Proceedings. American Institute of Physics. USA, 2015, pp. 1392. 60 Hu T P, Gao L M, Yang H N. Aeronautical Manufacturing Technology, 2018, 61(19), 50 (in Chinese). 胡婷萍, 高丽敏, 杨海楠. 航空制造技术, 2018, 61(19), 50. 61 Li L, Jiao J P, Gao X, et al. Chinese Science Bulletin. 2022, 67(7), 621 (in Chinese). 李立, 焦敬品, 高翔, 等. 科学通报, 2022, 67(7), 621. 62 Bai X B, Sun J G, Zhou J P, et al. Nondestructive Testing, 2013, 35(12), 46 (in Chinese). 白小宝, 孙建罡, 周建平, 等. 无损检测, 2013, 35(12), 46. 63 Ndiaye E B, Samet N, Marechal P, et al. In:Conference Record of the 13th International Symposium on Nondestructive Characterization of Materials. Le Mans, France, 2013, pp. 20. 64 Li Z Y, Liu F F, Yang Y S, et al. Aeronautical Manufacturing Technology. 2021, 64(19), 82 (in Chinese). 李治应, 刘菲菲, 杨玉森, 等. 航空制造技术, 2021, 64(19), 82. 65 Heida J H, Platenkamp D J. Materials Science, 2011, 10, 12. 66 Hou Z. Research on microwave detecting technology of composite material with internal defect. Master’s Thesis, Taiyuan University of Technology, China, 2014 (in Chinese). 侯哲. 复合材料内部缺陷的微波检测技术研究. 硕士学位论文, 太原理工大学, 2014. 67 Liu H X, Zhang H, Ma R X. Nondestructive Testing, 2003(12), 631 (in Chinese). 刘怀喜, 张恒, 马润香. 无损检测, 2003 (12), 631. 68 Haryono A, ur Rahman M S, Abou-Khousa M. In:2018 IEEE international RF and microwave conference (RFM), IEEE, Penang, 2018, pp. 219. 69 Xing H M, Ma Y, Duan Z H. Nondestructive Testing, 2013, 35(10), 18 (in Chinese). 邢贺民, 马耀, 段滋华. 无损检测, 2013, 35(10), 18. 70 Yang Y E, Yan T T, Ren B S. Journal of Aeronautical Materials, 2015, 35(6), 91 (in Chinese). 杨玉娥, 闫天婷, 任保胜. 航空材料学报, 2015, 35(6), 91. 71 Li Z, Haigh A, Soutis C, et al. Nondestructive Testing and Evaluation, 2019, 34(4), 429. 72 Li Z. Radio frequency non-destructive evaluation of impact damage in carbon fibre composites. Ph. D. Thesis, University of Manchester, UK, 2017. 73 Wang B, Liu W, Yu M, et al. Measurement & Control Technology. 2021, 40(11), 118 (in Chinese). 王彪, 刘伟, 于淼, 等. 测控技术, 2021, 40(11), 118. 74 Zhu H. Research on theoretical and experimental study of terahertz tomography. Master’s Thesis, University of Electronic Science and Technology of China, China, 2020 (in Chinese). 朱浩. 太赫兹层析成像的理论与实验研究. 硕士学位论文, 电子科技大学, 2020. 75 Hu B B, Nuss M C. Optics letters, 1995, 20(16), 1716. 76 Pan Z, Wen Y T, Zheng X K, et al. Acta Metrologica Sinica, 2018, 39(4), 471(in Chinese). 潘钊, 温银堂, 郑晓康, 等. 计量学报, 2018, 39(4), 471. 77 Ospald F, Zouaghi W, Beigang R, et al. Optical Engineering, 2013, 53(3), 031208. 78 Im K H, Kim S K, Jung J A, et al. Electronics, 2020, 9(9), 1360. 79 Cao B H, Li S Z, Cai E Z, et al. Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis, 2020, 40(9), 2686 (in Chinese). 曹丙花, 李素珍, 蔡恩泽, 等. 光谱学与光谱分析, 2020, 40(9), 2686. 80 Di Z G, Yao J Q, Jia C R, et al. Laser & Infrared , 2011, 41(10), 1163 (in Chinese). 邸志刚, 姚建铨, 贾春荣, 等. 激光与红外, 2011, 41(10), 1163. 81 Sun Z L. Research on terahertz fast imaging system. Master’s Thesis, Nanjing University, China, 2014 (in Chinese). 孙振龙. 太赫兹快速成像系统的研究. 硕士学位论文, 南京大学, 2014. 82 Zhang Y M. In:The 13th Annual Conference on NDT in Shaanxi Pro-vince. Xi’an, China, 2012, pp. 212 (in Chinese). 张永民. 陕西省第十三届无损检测年会. 西安, 2012, pp. 212. 83 Zhang Y. Experimental study of carbon/carbon composite materials non-destructive testing. Master’s Thesis, Tsinghua University, China, 2012 (in Chinese). 张毅. 碳/碳复合材料无损检测技术实验研究. 硕士学位论文, 清华大学, 2012. 84 Jandejsek I, Jakubek J, Jakubek M, et al. Journal of Instrumentation, 2014, 9(5), C05062. 85 Hungler P C, Bennett L G I, Lewis W J, et al. Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2011, 651(1), 250. 86 Tu J. Studies on laser shearographic NDT of honeycomb sandwich structure. Master’s Thesis, Nanchang Hangkong University, China, 2011 (in Chinese). 涂俊. 蜂窝夹层结构的激光错位散斑检测技术研究. 硕士学位论文, 南昌航空大学, 2011. 87 Guo X H, Sun F L. Nondestructive Testing, 2018, 40(3), 10 (in Chinese). 郭孝欢, 孙法亮. 无损检测, 2018, 40(3), 10. 88 Tamberg T R, Crompton M. The NDT Technician, 2011, 10(3), 1. 89 Yang Q F, Sun J L, Hu C, et al. Nondestructive Testing, 2019, 41(12), 45 (in Chinese). 杨庆峰, 孙金立, 胡丑, 等. 无损检测, 2019, 41(12), 45. 90 Yuan Y M, Chen X B. Nondestructive Testing, 2015, 37(5), 7 (in Chinese). 袁英民, 陈新波. 无损检测, 2015, 37(5), 7. 91 Duchene P, Chaki S, Ayadi A, et al. Journal of Materials Science, 2018, 53(11), 7915. 92 Li B L. Research on infrared nondestructive testing technology for water/ice in honeycomb skin. Master’s Thesis, Shanghai University of Engineering Science, China, 2020 (in Chinese). 李宝磊. 蜂窝蒙皮内部积水/积冰的红外无损检测技术研究. 硕士学位论文, 上海工程技术大学, 2020. 93 Wang M L. Defect depth retrieval method based on nonlinear transformation for pulsed thermographic inspection. Master’s Thesis, University of Electronic Science and Technology of China, China, 2021 (in Chinese). 汪美伶. 基于非线性变换的光激励热成像缺陷深度估计关键技术研究. 硕士学位论文, 电子科技大学, 2021. 94 Čapka A, Vavilov V, Rusnáková S, et al. In:Materials Science Forum. Trans Tech Publications Ltd, Switzerland, 2017, pp. 516. 95 Kumar S S, Kumar M R, Sudheendra H N, et al. Insight-Non-Destructive Testing and Condition Monitoring, 2011, 53(6), 312. 96 Gruber J, Stotter B, Mayr G, et al. In:AIP Conference Proceedings. American Institute of Physics. USA, 2013, pp. 547. 97 Wang Z Z. Design and implementation of heating source system for large-size infrared thermal imaging nondestructive testing. Master’s Thesis, University of Electronic Science and Technology of China, China, 2021 (in Chinese). 王增增. 大尺寸红外热成像无损检测加热源系统设计与实现. 硕士学位论文, 电子科技大学, 2021. 98 He Y H. Experimental research on damage in the airplane skin by means of lock-in thermography. Master’s Thesis, Harbin Institute of Technology, China, 2009 (in Chinese). 何银行. 基于红外锁相法的飞机蒙皮损伤检测试验研究. 硕士学位论文, 哈尔滨工业大学, 2009. 99 Liu H, Liu J Y, Wang Y, et al. In:Advanced Materials Research. Trans Tech Publications Ltd, Switzerland, 2010, pp. 4363. 100 Wu S C. Research on nondestructive testing technology of infrared thermography composites based on multi-mode excitation. Master’s Thesis, University of Electronic Science and Technology of China, China, 2019 (in Chinese). 吴世春. 基于多模态激励的红外热成像复合材料无损检测技术研究. 硕士学位论文, 电子科技大学, 2019. 101 Tabatabaei N, Mandelis A. Physical Review Letters, 2011, 107(16), 165901. 102 Mulaveesala R, Tuli S. Applied Physics Letters, 2006, 89(19), 191913. 103 Shrestha R, Choi M, Kim W. Quantitative InfraRed Thermography Journal, 2021, 18(2), 92. 104 Zhu P, Yin C, Cheng Y, et al. Mechanical Systems and Signal Proces-sing, 2018, 113, 5. 105 Usamentiaga R, Venegas P, Guerediaga J, et al. Sensors, 2014, 14(7), 12305. 106 Xu Z, Chen H, Qu Z, et al. Materials, 2022, 15(16), 5689. 107 Xu Z, Wu X, Li J, et al. NDT & E International, 2012, 51, 24. 108 Huang C. Research on the experiments of non-destructive testing based on pulsed eddy currents technology. Master’s Thesis, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, China, 2007 (in Chinese). 黄琛. 基于脉冲涡流技术的无损检测实验研究. 硕士学位论文, 华中科技大学, 2007. 109 He Y, Tian G Y, Pan M, et al. Composites Part B:Engineering, 2014, 59, 196. 110 Underhill P R, Rellinger T, Krause T W, et al. Journal of Nondestructive Evaluation, Diagnostics and Prognostics of Engineering Systems, 2020, 3(3), 031104. 111 Jiao S N. Research on eddy current testing of carbon fiber reinforced polymers and aluminum honeycomb sandwich structure. Ph. D. Thesis, Xiamen University, China, 2017 (in Chinese). 焦少妮. 碳纤维复合材料及铝蜂窝夹层结构涡流检测研究. 博士学位论文, 厦门大学, 2017. 112 Wu J, Zhou D, Wang J. Journal of Sensors, 2014, 2014, 1687. 113 Meng Q F. Study on evaluation method of defect in carbon fibre reinforced plastic plate based on magnetic induction tomography. Master’s Thesis, Nanchang Hangkong University, China, 2019 (in Chinese). 孟杞凤. 基于磁感应断层成像技术的CFRP缺陷评价方法研究. 硕士学位论文, 南昌航空大学, 2019. 114 Cagáň J, Michalcová L. Journal of Nondestructive Evaluation, 2020, 39(2), 1. 115 Wang B. Research on damage detection system of CFRP laminates based on EIT. Master’s Thesis, Civil Aviation University of China, China, 2019 (in Chinese). 王勃. 基于EIT的CFRP层合板结构损伤检测系统研究. 硕士学位论文, 中国民航大学, 2019. 116 Peng W, Zhang Y, Qiu B, et al. Aasri Procedia, 2012, 2, 127. 117 Pyzik P, Ziaja-Sujdak A, Spytek J, et al. Photoacoustics, 2021, 21, 100226. 118 Chakraborty N, Rathod V T, Mahapatra D R, et al. Ndt & E International, 2012, 49, 27. 119 Matzkanin G A, Yolken H T. Welding Journal, 2008, 87(5), 26. 120 Vary A. In:Office of Naval Res. Conf. A Critical Rev:Tech. for the Characterization of Composite Mater. United States, 1981, 40(6), 650. 121 Ghoni R, Dollah M, Sulaiman A, et al. Advances in Mechanical Engineering, 2014, 6, 182496. 122 Balageas D, Maldague X, Burleigh D, et al. Journal of Nondestructive Evaluation, 2016, 35(1), 1. 123 Hao W, Li M, Wang Y, et al. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica, 2022, 43(7), 438 (in Chinese). 郝威, 李明, 王珏, 等. 航空学报, 2022, 43(7), 438. 124 Rellinger T, Underhill P R, Krause T W, et al. NDT & E Internatio-nal, 2021, 120, 102421. 125 Daryabor P, Safizadeh M S. Ndt & E International, 2017, 90, 1. 126 Zhao L Y, Wu Y Q. Chinese Journal of Scientific Instrument, 2022, 43(1), 198 (in Chinese). 赵朗月, 吴一全. 仪器仪表学报, 2022, 43(1), 198. 127 Modarres C, Astorga N, Droguett E L, et al. Structural Control and Health Monitoring, 2018, 25(10), e2230. 128 Yang F. Research on infrared thermal wave detection and convolutional neural network recognition of hscs defects. Master’s Thesis, Harbin Institute of Technology, China, 2021 (in Chinese). 杨峰. 蜂窝夹层结构缺陷红外热波检测与卷积神经网络识别研究. 硕士学位论文, 哈尔滨工业大学, 2021. 129 Li J Y. Research on damage detection of CFRP laminates based on electrical impedance tomography. Master’s Thesis, Civil Aviation University of China, China, 2020 (in Chinese). 李靓瑶. 基于电阻抗成像的CFRP层压板损伤检测研究. 硕士学位论文, 中国民航大学, 2020. 130 Wang Y, Lu L, Song H. In:IOP Conference Series:Materials Science and Engineering. IOP Publishing, India, 2019, 563(4), 042028.